“These are young people trying to earn a living. Wangekuwa US wangekuwa private security,” said Alai.
He suggested that, in a different context, such individuals could be formally employed in structured sectors such as private security, where their roles would be recognised and regulated.
According to him, the distinction lies not in the nature of the individuals themselves, but in the availability of opportunities and systems that support formal employment.
Alai’s comments have sparked debate over how society perceives and addresses youth involvement in informal or loosely organised activities.
While some critics argue that such groups are often linked to disorder or insecurity, others agree with his position that economic hardship plays a significant role in pushing young people into unconventional means of survival.
The MCA emphasised the need for a more balanced approach, urging authorities and the public to consider underlying socio-economic factors rather than relying solely on labels.
He noted that many young people are forced to navigate a difficult environment with limited access to stable jobs, making informal work a common alternative.
His remarks also highlight broader concerns about youth unemployment and the need for inclusive economic policies that create sustainable livelihoods.
Observers say addressing these challenges requires long-term investment in education, skills development and job creation to absorb the growing number of young people entering the workforce.
At the same time, there have been calls for clearer regulation and accountability in sectors where informal labour is prevalent, to ensure that activities remain within the bounds of the law and do not compromise public safety.
This, analysts argue, would help strike a balance between supporting livelihoods and maintaining order.