After she returned to school, the two reportedly kept in touch through WhatsApp, Instagram and TikTok, maintaining communication over time.
In 2026, the pair are said to have planned a reunion on a Saturday afternoon.
However, Connie later informed Tonny that she was still having her hair done, eventually finishing at around 10pm.
She is said to have then joined him in Hurlingham, where they spent several hours together at an Ethiopian restaurant before leaving at about 3am.
While heading to Kaisa Gardens, Tonny claims Connie began acting unusually and mentioned that a doctor had told her she would die soon.
Upon arriving at the apartment, security officers reportedly assisted the pair due to her uncooperative behaviour.
Once inside the house, the two are said to have discovered there was no electricity token.
Tonny says he went to rest in the bedroom, leaving Connie in the sitting room. He later claims he heard her repeatedly calling out, “Lawal bye, Lawal bye.”
He says he rushed out and found her seated on the sitting room window with one leg outside and the other inside.
After pulling her back, a struggle is said to have followed near the door as he attempted to remove her from the apartment while she resisted.
Tonny then contacted the host, who alerted security officers. During the tense moments, he is said to have started recording as Connie allegedly stated that her family hated her.
Security officers intervened and secured the sitting room window before briefly leaving to top up the electricity token so she could collect her belongings.
Tonny says that while he remained seated in distress, Connie later walked toward the bedroom.
Moments later, he again heard her call out the same words. He rushed in and found her seated on the bedroom window in a similar position.
Before he could reach her, he claims she leaned outward and fell.